What happens when a very fast creature opens an Eversmoking Bottle, then moves far away?












5














The Eversmoking Bottle magic item has the following details:




Smoke leaks from the lead-stoppered mouth of this brass bottle, which weighs 1 pound. When you use an action to remove the stopper, a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle. The cloud's area is heavily obscured. Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.



The cloud persists as long as the bottle is open. Closing the bottle requires you to speak its command word as an action. Once the bottle is closed, the cloud disperses after 10 minutes. A moderate wind (11 to 20 miles per hour) can also disperse the smoke after 1 minute, and a strong wind (21 or more miles per hour) can do so after 1 round.




What happens if a very fast creature opens the bottle, then immediately moves far away from the smoke (e.g. 500 ft.)?




  1. The smoke follows the creature to the destination, but without leaving a trail on the way

  2. Smoke is generated along the way as well, making a 60ft wide, 500ft long line of smoke

  3. Smoke is only generated at the start of the creature's turns, so if he stops 500ft away and waits for his next turn, a single new 60ft cloud will be made there

  4. The smoke is only generated once (upon opening time), no additional smoke will be generated neither on the way to the destination, or at the destination itself

  5. Other behaviour










share|improve this question





























    5














    The Eversmoking Bottle magic item has the following details:




    Smoke leaks from the lead-stoppered mouth of this brass bottle, which weighs 1 pound. When you use an action to remove the stopper, a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle. The cloud's area is heavily obscured. Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.



    The cloud persists as long as the bottle is open. Closing the bottle requires you to speak its command word as an action. Once the bottle is closed, the cloud disperses after 10 minutes. A moderate wind (11 to 20 miles per hour) can also disperse the smoke after 1 minute, and a strong wind (21 or more miles per hour) can do so after 1 round.




    What happens if a very fast creature opens the bottle, then immediately moves far away from the smoke (e.g. 500 ft.)?




    1. The smoke follows the creature to the destination, but without leaving a trail on the way

    2. Smoke is generated along the way as well, making a 60ft wide, 500ft long line of smoke

    3. Smoke is only generated at the start of the creature's turns, so if he stops 500ft away and waits for his next turn, a single new 60ft cloud will be made there

    4. The smoke is only generated once (upon opening time), no additional smoke will be generated neither on the way to the destination, or at the destination itself

    5. Other behaviour










    share|improve this question



























      5












      5








      5







      The Eversmoking Bottle magic item has the following details:




      Smoke leaks from the lead-stoppered mouth of this brass bottle, which weighs 1 pound. When you use an action to remove the stopper, a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle. The cloud's area is heavily obscured. Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.



      The cloud persists as long as the bottle is open. Closing the bottle requires you to speak its command word as an action. Once the bottle is closed, the cloud disperses after 10 minutes. A moderate wind (11 to 20 miles per hour) can also disperse the smoke after 1 minute, and a strong wind (21 or more miles per hour) can do so after 1 round.




      What happens if a very fast creature opens the bottle, then immediately moves far away from the smoke (e.g. 500 ft.)?




      1. The smoke follows the creature to the destination, but without leaving a trail on the way

      2. Smoke is generated along the way as well, making a 60ft wide, 500ft long line of smoke

      3. Smoke is only generated at the start of the creature's turns, so if he stops 500ft away and waits for his next turn, a single new 60ft cloud will be made there

      4. The smoke is only generated once (upon opening time), no additional smoke will be generated neither on the way to the destination, or at the destination itself

      5. Other behaviour










      share|improve this question















      The Eversmoking Bottle magic item has the following details:




      Smoke leaks from the lead-stoppered mouth of this brass bottle, which weighs 1 pound. When you use an action to remove the stopper, a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle. The cloud's area is heavily obscured. Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.



      The cloud persists as long as the bottle is open. Closing the bottle requires you to speak its command word as an action. Once the bottle is closed, the cloud disperses after 10 minutes. A moderate wind (11 to 20 miles per hour) can also disperse the smoke after 1 minute, and a strong wind (21 or more miles per hour) can do so after 1 round.




      What happens if a very fast creature opens the bottle, then immediately moves far away from the smoke (e.g. 500 ft.)?




      1. The smoke follows the creature to the destination, but without leaving a trail on the way

      2. Smoke is generated along the way as well, making a 60ft wide, 500ft long line of smoke

      3. Smoke is only generated at the start of the creature's turns, so if he stops 500ft away and waits for his next turn, a single new 60ft cloud will be made there

      4. The smoke is only generated once (upon opening time), no additional smoke will be generated neither on the way to the destination, or at the destination itself

      5. Other behaviour







      dnd-5e magic-items movement






      share|improve this question















      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question








      edited 59 mins ago









      V2Blast

      19.7k356121




      19.7k356121










      asked 4 hours ago









      Gael L

      8,069232146




      8,069232146






















          2 Answers
          2






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          10














          Option #4: The smoke only exists at the initial point of creation.



          There are a few important points in your quote:




          When you use an action to remove the stopper, a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle. [...] Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.




          Note that other than the initial opening of the bottle, no other mention of the cloud's position refers to the bottle. Additionally, in order for the cloud to continue growing, the bottle must remain within its range.



          While a "60-foot radius from the bottle" almost describes the fog as an aura that follows the bottle, it distinctly states that the bottle has to remain within the cloud for the full effect, so its implied that the cloud can be separated from the bottle.



          If you were to move out of the cloud, the cloud would sit in place, cease to grow, and disappear when you cork the bottle (or by a stiff wind or the duration running out).






          share|improve this answer



















          • 1




            Ah! I thought that, since the cloud expands if you stand there for a while, it would imply that it is constantly spewing more smoke (fitting for the "Eversmoking" adjective!), making me lean towards option #2.
            – Gael L
            4 hours ago










          • @GaelL I edited the end of the main paragraph to explain why I think that's not the case.
            – Daniel Zastoupil
            4 hours ago












          • Hmmm. That makes sense. I'll still wait for additional answers, but yours seems valid.
            – Gael L
            4 hours ago



















          6














          #4 The cloud remains where it was summoned but does not vanish (unless the requirements for dissipation are met).



          First, the bottle only generates one cloud of smoke:




          a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle




          Next, the bottle must remain within that cloud to increase the cloud's size:




          Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.




          In real life, there would be a trail of smoke and one might consider that as being part of the same cloud, but the spell's description does not say "it continues to billow smoke" but that the cloud increases in size. It would be logical to interpret the cloud's increase in size as the result of more smoke being added to it from the bottle, but this is one of those times where a magical effect doesn't even come close to mirroring what you'd expect to happen in reality. It's magic (not physics) and a game (not a simulation)!



          It's also moot, because once/as long as the bottle is outside of the cloud's area, the cloud stops growing but does not begin to disperse (unless there's a strong enough wind) because:




          The cloud persists as long as the bottle is open [...] Once the bottle is closed, the cloud disperses after 10 minutes.




          So in your scenario, the initial cloud of 60' radius is created, the bottle bearer rapidly moves out of its area, stopping the growth. No new cloud is created but the old one stays in place at the same size until the bottle is restoppered or a strong enough wind begins to dissipate the cloud.






          share|improve this answer























            Your Answer





            StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
            return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
            StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
            StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["\$", "\$"]]);
            });
            });
            }, "mathjax-editing");

            StackExchange.ready(function() {
            var channelOptions = {
            tags: "".split(" "),
            id: "122"
            };
            initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

            StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
            // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
            if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
            StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
            createEditor();
            });
            }
            else {
            createEditor();
            }
            });

            function createEditor() {
            StackExchange.prepareEditor({
            heartbeatType: 'answer',
            autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
            convertImagesToLinks: false,
            noModals: true,
            showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
            reputationToPostImages: null,
            bindNavPrevention: true,
            postfix: "",
            imageUploader: {
            brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
            contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
            allowUrls: true
            },
            noCode: true, onDemand: true,
            discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
            ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
            });


            }
            });














            draft saved

            draft discarded


















            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f138487%2fwhat-happens-when-a-very-fast-creature-opens-an-eversmoking-bottle-then-moves-f%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown

























            2 Answers
            2






            active

            oldest

            votes








            2 Answers
            2






            active

            oldest

            votes









            active

            oldest

            votes






            active

            oldest

            votes









            10














            Option #4: The smoke only exists at the initial point of creation.



            There are a few important points in your quote:




            When you use an action to remove the stopper, a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle. [...] Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.




            Note that other than the initial opening of the bottle, no other mention of the cloud's position refers to the bottle. Additionally, in order for the cloud to continue growing, the bottle must remain within its range.



            While a "60-foot radius from the bottle" almost describes the fog as an aura that follows the bottle, it distinctly states that the bottle has to remain within the cloud for the full effect, so its implied that the cloud can be separated from the bottle.



            If you were to move out of the cloud, the cloud would sit in place, cease to grow, and disappear when you cork the bottle (or by a stiff wind or the duration running out).






            share|improve this answer



















            • 1




              Ah! I thought that, since the cloud expands if you stand there for a while, it would imply that it is constantly spewing more smoke (fitting for the "Eversmoking" adjective!), making me lean towards option #2.
              – Gael L
              4 hours ago










            • @GaelL I edited the end of the main paragraph to explain why I think that's not the case.
              – Daniel Zastoupil
              4 hours ago












            • Hmmm. That makes sense. I'll still wait for additional answers, but yours seems valid.
              – Gael L
              4 hours ago
















            10














            Option #4: The smoke only exists at the initial point of creation.



            There are a few important points in your quote:




            When you use an action to remove the stopper, a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle. [...] Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.




            Note that other than the initial opening of the bottle, no other mention of the cloud's position refers to the bottle. Additionally, in order for the cloud to continue growing, the bottle must remain within its range.



            While a "60-foot radius from the bottle" almost describes the fog as an aura that follows the bottle, it distinctly states that the bottle has to remain within the cloud for the full effect, so its implied that the cloud can be separated from the bottle.



            If you were to move out of the cloud, the cloud would sit in place, cease to grow, and disappear when you cork the bottle (or by a stiff wind or the duration running out).






            share|improve this answer



















            • 1




              Ah! I thought that, since the cloud expands if you stand there for a while, it would imply that it is constantly spewing more smoke (fitting for the "Eversmoking" adjective!), making me lean towards option #2.
              – Gael L
              4 hours ago










            • @GaelL I edited the end of the main paragraph to explain why I think that's not the case.
              – Daniel Zastoupil
              4 hours ago












            • Hmmm. That makes sense. I'll still wait for additional answers, but yours seems valid.
              – Gael L
              4 hours ago














            10












            10








            10






            Option #4: The smoke only exists at the initial point of creation.



            There are a few important points in your quote:




            When you use an action to remove the stopper, a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle. [...] Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.




            Note that other than the initial opening of the bottle, no other mention of the cloud's position refers to the bottle. Additionally, in order for the cloud to continue growing, the bottle must remain within its range.



            While a "60-foot radius from the bottle" almost describes the fog as an aura that follows the bottle, it distinctly states that the bottle has to remain within the cloud for the full effect, so its implied that the cloud can be separated from the bottle.



            If you were to move out of the cloud, the cloud would sit in place, cease to grow, and disappear when you cork the bottle (or by a stiff wind or the duration running out).






            share|improve this answer














            Option #4: The smoke only exists at the initial point of creation.



            There are a few important points in your quote:




            When you use an action to remove the stopper, a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle. [...] Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.




            Note that other than the initial opening of the bottle, no other mention of the cloud's position refers to the bottle. Additionally, in order for the cloud to continue growing, the bottle must remain within its range.



            While a "60-foot radius from the bottle" almost describes the fog as an aura that follows the bottle, it distinctly states that the bottle has to remain within the cloud for the full effect, so its implied that the cloud can be separated from the bottle.



            If you were to move out of the cloud, the cloud would sit in place, cease to grow, and disappear when you cork the bottle (or by a stiff wind or the duration running out).







            share|improve this answer














            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer








            edited 4 hours ago

























            answered 4 hours ago









            Daniel Zastoupil

            7,43011681




            7,43011681








            • 1




              Ah! I thought that, since the cloud expands if you stand there for a while, it would imply that it is constantly spewing more smoke (fitting for the "Eversmoking" adjective!), making me lean towards option #2.
              – Gael L
              4 hours ago










            • @GaelL I edited the end of the main paragraph to explain why I think that's not the case.
              – Daniel Zastoupil
              4 hours ago












            • Hmmm. That makes sense. I'll still wait for additional answers, but yours seems valid.
              – Gael L
              4 hours ago














            • 1




              Ah! I thought that, since the cloud expands if you stand there for a while, it would imply that it is constantly spewing more smoke (fitting for the "Eversmoking" adjective!), making me lean towards option #2.
              – Gael L
              4 hours ago










            • @GaelL I edited the end of the main paragraph to explain why I think that's not the case.
              – Daniel Zastoupil
              4 hours ago












            • Hmmm. That makes sense. I'll still wait for additional answers, but yours seems valid.
              – Gael L
              4 hours ago








            1




            1




            Ah! I thought that, since the cloud expands if you stand there for a while, it would imply that it is constantly spewing more smoke (fitting for the "Eversmoking" adjective!), making me lean towards option #2.
            – Gael L
            4 hours ago




            Ah! I thought that, since the cloud expands if you stand there for a while, it would imply that it is constantly spewing more smoke (fitting for the "Eversmoking" adjective!), making me lean towards option #2.
            – Gael L
            4 hours ago












            @GaelL I edited the end of the main paragraph to explain why I think that's not the case.
            – Daniel Zastoupil
            4 hours ago






            @GaelL I edited the end of the main paragraph to explain why I think that's not the case.
            – Daniel Zastoupil
            4 hours ago














            Hmmm. That makes sense. I'll still wait for additional answers, but yours seems valid.
            – Gael L
            4 hours ago




            Hmmm. That makes sense. I'll still wait for additional answers, but yours seems valid.
            – Gael L
            4 hours ago













            6














            #4 The cloud remains where it was summoned but does not vanish (unless the requirements for dissipation are met).



            First, the bottle only generates one cloud of smoke:




            a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle




            Next, the bottle must remain within that cloud to increase the cloud's size:




            Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.




            In real life, there would be a trail of smoke and one might consider that as being part of the same cloud, but the spell's description does not say "it continues to billow smoke" but that the cloud increases in size. It would be logical to interpret the cloud's increase in size as the result of more smoke being added to it from the bottle, but this is one of those times where a magical effect doesn't even come close to mirroring what you'd expect to happen in reality. It's magic (not physics) and a game (not a simulation)!



            It's also moot, because once/as long as the bottle is outside of the cloud's area, the cloud stops growing but does not begin to disperse (unless there's a strong enough wind) because:




            The cloud persists as long as the bottle is open [...] Once the bottle is closed, the cloud disperses after 10 minutes.




            So in your scenario, the initial cloud of 60' radius is created, the bottle bearer rapidly moves out of its area, stopping the growth. No new cloud is created but the old one stays in place at the same size until the bottle is restoppered or a strong enough wind begins to dissipate the cloud.






            share|improve this answer




























              6














              #4 The cloud remains where it was summoned but does not vanish (unless the requirements for dissipation are met).



              First, the bottle only generates one cloud of smoke:




              a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle




              Next, the bottle must remain within that cloud to increase the cloud's size:




              Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.




              In real life, there would be a trail of smoke and one might consider that as being part of the same cloud, but the spell's description does not say "it continues to billow smoke" but that the cloud increases in size. It would be logical to interpret the cloud's increase in size as the result of more smoke being added to it from the bottle, but this is one of those times where a magical effect doesn't even come close to mirroring what you'd expect to happen in reality. It's magic (not physics) and a game (not a simulation)!



              It's also moot, because once/as long as the bottle is outside of the cloud's area, the cloud stops growing but does not begin to disperse (unless there's a strong enough wind) because:




              The cloud persists as long as the bottle is open [...] Once the bottle is closed, the cloud disperses after 10 minutes.




              So in your scenario, the initial cloud of 60' radius is created, the bottle bearer rapidly moves out of its area, stopping the growth. No new cloud is created but the old one stays in place at the same size until the bottle is restoppered or a strong enough wind begins to dissipate the cloud.






              share|improve this answer


























                6












                6








                6






                #4 The cloud remains where it was summoned but does not vanish (unless the requirements for dissipation are met).



                First, the bottle only generates one cloud of smoke:




                a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle




                Next, the bottle must remain within that cloud to increase the cloud's size:




                Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.




                In real life, there would be a trail of smoke and one might consider that as being part of the same cloud, but the spell's description does not say "it continues to billow smoke" but that the cloud increases in size. It would be logical to interpret the cloud's increase in size as the result of more smoke being added to it from the bottle, but this is one of those times where a magical effect doesn't even come close to mirroring what you'd expect to happen in reality. It's magic (not physics) and a game (not a simulation)!



                It's also moot, because once/as long as the bottle is outside of the cloud's area, the cloud stops growing but does not begin to disperse (unless there's a strong enough wind) because:




                The cloud persists as long as the bottle is open [...] Once the bottle is closed, the cloud disperses after 10 minutes.




                So in your scenario, the initial cloud of 60' radius is created, the bottle bearer rapidly moves out of its area, stopping the growth. No new cloud is created but the old one stays in place at the same size until the bottle is restoppered or a strong enough wind begins to dissipate the cloud.






                share|improve this answer














                #4 The cloud remains where it was summoned but does not vanish (unless the requirements for dissipation are met).



                First, the bottle only generates one cloud of smoke:




                a cloud of thick smoke pours out in a 60-foot radius from the bottle




                Next, the bottle must remain within that cloud to increase the cloud's size:




                Each minute the bottle remains open and within the cloud, the radius increases by 10 feet until it reaches its maximum radius of 120 feet.




                In real life, there would be a trail of smoke and one might consider that as being part of the same cloud, but the spell's description does not say "it continues to billow smoke" but that the cloud increases in size. It would be logical to interpret the cloud's increase in size as the result of more smoke being added to it from the bottle, but this is one of those times where a magical effect doesn't even come close to mirroring what you'd expect to happen in reality. It's magic (not physics) and a game (not a simulation)!



                It's also moot, because once/as long as the bottle is outside of the cloud's area, the cloud stops growing but does not begin to disperse (unless there's a strong enough wind) because:




                The cloud persists as long as the bottle is open [...] Once the bottle is closed, the cloud disperses after 10 minutes.




                So in your scenario, the initial cloud of 60' radius is created, the bottle bearer rapidly moves out of its area, stopping the growth. No new cloud is created but the old one stays in place at the same size until the bottle is restoppered or a strong enough wind begins to dissipate the cloud.







                share|improve this answer














                share|improve this answer



                share|improve this answer








                edited 4 hours ago

























                answered 4 hours ago









                Rykara

                2,508325




                2,508325






























                    draft saved

                    draft discarded




















































                    Thanks for contributing an answer to Role-playing Games Stack Exchange!


                    • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                    But avoid



                    • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                    • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                    Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


                    To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.





                    Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.


                    Please pay close attention to the following guidance:


                    • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                    But avoid



                    • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                    • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                    To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                    draft saved


                    draft discarded














                    StackExchange.ready(
                    function () {
                    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f138487%2fwhat-happens-when-a-very-fast-creature-opens-an-eversmoking-bottle-then-moves-f%23new-answer', 'question_page');
                    }
                    );

                    Post as a guest















                    Required, but never shown





















































                    Required, but never shown














                    Required, but never shown












                    Required, but never shown







                    Required, but never shown

































                    Required, but never shown














                    Required, but never shown












                    Required, but never shown







                    Required, but never shown







                    Popular posts from this blog

                    Eastern Orthodox Church

                    Zagreb

                    Understanding the information contained in the Deep Space Network XML data?