Ykhjuy

E. D. Morel
Member of Parliament for Dundee
In office 1922–1924 Serving with Edwin Scrymgeour
Preceded by	Winston Churchill Alexander Wilkie
Succeeded by	Tom Johnston Edwin Scrymgeour
Majority	32,846 (26.5%)
Personal details
Born	10 July 1873 Paris, France
Died	12 November 1924(1924-11-12) (aged 51) Devon, England
Occupation	Journalist, author, politician

Edmund Dene Morel (born Georges Eduard Pierre Achille Morel de Ville; 10 July 1873 – 12 November 1924) was a British journalist, author, pacifist, and politician.

As a young official at the shipping company Elder Dempster, Morel observed a fortune in rubber returning from the Congo while only guns and manacles were being sent in return. He correctly deduced that these resources were being extracted from the population by force and began to campaign to expose the abuses. In collaboration with Roger Casement, Morel led a campaign against slavery in the Congo Free State, founding the Congo Reform Association and running the West African Mail. With the help of celebrities such as Arthur Conan Doyle and Mark Twain, the movement successfully pressured the Belgian King Leopold II to turn over the Congo to the Belgian government, ending some of the human rights abuses perpetrated under his rule.

Morel played a significant role in the British pacifist movement during the First World War, participating in the foundation of and becoming secretary of the Union of Democratic Control, at which point he broke with the Liberal Party. In 1917, he was jailed for six months for his antiwar activism, which had a permanent effect on his health. After the war, he edited the journal Foreign Affairs, through which he sharply criticized what he considered French aggression and mistreatment of the defeated Central Powers. As part of his campaign against the French, he became the most important English proponent of the racist Black Shame campaign, which accused "black" French troops (actually North Africans) of outrages against the population of the occupied Rhineland.

Morel was elected to Parliament in 1922 as a Labour candidate, defeating the incumbent Winston Churchill for his seat, and was reelected in 1924, dying in office. Morel collaborated closely with future prime minister Ramsay MacDonald and was considered for the post of Foreign Secretary, though he ultimately acted only as an unofficial adviser to MacDonald's government.

Background

Morel was born in the Avenue d'Eylau, Paris. His father, Edmond Morel de Ville, was a French civil servant; his mother, Emmeline de Horne, was from an English Quaker family. Edmond died when the boy was four, leaving no pension,^[1] and Emmeline subsequently fell out with her late husband's family. As a consequence, Emmeline changed her name to Deville and raised her son on her own. To remove her son from the family's influence, she worked as a teacher so that she could send him to boarding school at both Madras House school in Eastbourne and later at Bedford Modern School.

When Emmeline Deville fell ill in 1888, the money for school fees was no longer available and Edmund was forced to return to Paris to work as a bank clerk.^[2] He was able to move his mother back to Britain in 1891. Five years later he successfully applied for naturalisation as a British subject and anglicised his name. He married Mary Richardson that same year; they had five children. His daughter Stella married the Polish political advisor Joseph Retinger in 1926; they had two daughters.

Congo activism

Discoveries at Elder Dempster

Red Rubber: "The Story of the Rubber Slave Trade Flourishing on the Congo in the Year of Grace, 1906"

In 1891, Morel obtained a clerkship with Elder Dempster, a Liverpool shipping firm.^[3] To increase his income and support his family, from 1893 Morel began writing articles against French protectionism, which was damaging Elder Dempster's business. He came to be critical of the Foreign Office for not supporting the rights of Africans under colonial rule. His vision of Africa was influenced by the books of Mary Kingsley, an English traveller and writer, which showed sympathy for African peoples and a respect for different cultures that was very rare amongst Europeans at the time.^[4] Groups such as the Aborigines' Protection Society had already begun a campaign against alleged atrocities in Congo.^[5]

Elder Dempster had a shipping contract with the Congo Free State for the connection between Antwerp and Boma. Due to his knowledge of French, Morel was often sent to Belgium, where he was able to view the internal accounts of the Congo Free State held by Elder Dempster. The knowledge that the ships leaving Belgium for the Congo carried only guns, chains, ordnance and explosives, but no commercial goods, while ships arriving from the colony came back full of valuable products such as raw rubber and ivory, led him to the conclusion that Belgian King Leopold II's policy was exploitative and a type of slavery.^[6] According to author Adam Hochschild, Morel's conclusions were correct—the value of the goods coming from the Congo Free State was five times that of the goods coming from Europe, and the difference was being extracted from the Congolese population through force and mass atrocities.^[7]

Morel discussed the discrepancies with the head of the Elder Dempster line, who responded coldly and dismissively. The company soon offered Morel an overseas promotion and then a sinecure consultancy in return for a guarantee of his silence. Morel refused both offers, and left the company in 1901 to become a full-time journalist.^[8]

Journalism and Congo Reform Association

In 1900, Morel put new life into the campaign against Congo misrule (begun a decade before by the American George Washington Williams) with a series of articles detailing his discoveries about the Congo Free State trade imbalances.^[3] His inside information made him a powerful voice against the exploitation, as previous activists had lacked his access to precise figures about the trade.^[9] In 1903, he founded his own magazine, the West African Mail, with the collaboration of John Holt. John Holt was a businessman and friend of Mary Kingsley, who feared the system of the Congo Free State would be applied upon the rest of the West African colonies. The Mail was an "illustrated weekly journal founded to meet the rapidly growing interest in west and central African questions".^[10] The paper also received initial financial backing from Sir Alfred Lewis Jones, Morel's former employer at Elder Dempster, apparently in a final attempt to moderate Morel's criticism of the company; Jones soon discontinued his support.^[11] During this period Morel published several pamphlets and his first book, Affairs of West Africa, a collection of his essays.^[12]

Roger Casement's 1904 report confirmed Morel's accusations

In 1903, under pressure from Morel's campaign, the British House of Commons passed a resolution protesting human rights abuses in the Congo.^[3][13] Subsequently, the British consul in the Congo, Roger Casement, was sent up country by the Foreign Office for an investigation.^[14] Casement was outraged by the evidence of atrocities that he discovered and wrote a blistering report in 1904, discussing its contents with the London press even before its official release.^[15] Morel was introduced to Casement by their mutual friend Herbert Ward just before the publication of the report and realised that in Casement he had found the ally he had sought.^[16][17] Casement convinced Morel to establish an organisation for dealing specifically with the Congo question, the Congo Reform Association; because of the restrictions placed on Casement by his official duties, Morel would be the organisation's head.^[18] Affiliates of the Congo Reform Association were established as far away as the United States.

The Belgian socialist leader Emile Vandervelde aided Morel by sending him copies of parliamentary debates

The Congo Reform Association had the support of famous writers such as Joseph Conrad (whose Heart of Darkness was inspired by a voyage to the Congo Free State),^[19]Anatole France,^[20]Nobel laureates Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson and John Galsworthy,^[20][21]Sherlock Holmes creator Arthur Conan Doyle,^[22] civil rights activist Booker T. Washington,^[23] and Mark Twain.^[23] Conan Doyle wrote The Crime of the Congo in 1908,^[22] while Twain gave the most famous contribution with the satirical short story "King Leopold's Soliloquy".^[23] Conrad and Ford Madox Ford also included a devastating parody of Leopold II in their cowritten novel The Inheritors.^[24]

Morel's best allies, however, may have been the Christian missionaries who furnished him with eyewitness accounts and photographs of the atrocities, such as those given by the Americans William Morrison and William Henry Sheppard,^[25] and the British John Hobbis Harris and Alice Harris.^[26] The chocolate millionaire William Cadbury, a Quaker, was one of his main financial backers.^[27] The Belgian socialist leader Emile Vandervelde sent him copies of Belgian parliamentary debates and was recruited by Morel to successfully defend the missionaries Sheppard and Morrison pro bono in a libel suit brought by Kasai Rubber Company.^[28] Morel also had secret connections with some agents within the Congo Free State itself. Even the Church of England and American religious groups backed him.

In 1905 the movement won a victory when a Commission of Enquiry, instituted (under external pressure) by King Léopold II himself, substantially confirmed the accusations made about the colonial administration.^[29] In the face of mounting public and diplomatic pressure, in 1908 the Congo was annexed to the Belgian government and put under its sovereignty.^[30] Despite this, Morel refused to declare an end to the campaign until 1913 because he wanted to see actual changes in the situation of the country. The Congo Reform Association ended operations in 1913.^[31]

World War I activism

E.D. Morel before WWI

Foreign policy

During the Agadir Crisis of 1911, Morel was entirely in sympathy with Germany and opposed to what he regarded as bellicosity by the United Kingdom and France, as well as secret diplomacy between the states involved.^[32] He wrote Morocco in Diplomacy (1912) to express his views on the issue. At this time he was also selected by the Liberal Party as a prospective House of Commons candidate for Birkenhead.

Pacifism and formation of Union of Democratic Control

As the tension grew in the run-up to World War I, Morel was again sympathetic to Germany, disinclined to stand by Belgium under German pressure, and opposed to the United Kingdom and France getting involved in war. He campaigned for neutrality but on the outbreak of war accepted that the fight was lost, and with Charles Trevelyan, Norman Angell and Ramsay MacDonald, formed the Union of Democratic Control to press for a more responsive foreign policy (he also resigned his candidature at this time). He was Secretary of the UDC until his death. The main demands of the UDC were: (1) that in future to prevent secret diplomacy there should be parliamentary control over foreign policy; (2) there should be negotiations after the war with other democratic European countries in an attempt to form an organisation to help prevent future conflicts; (3) that at the end of the war the terms of peace should neither humiliate the defeated nation nor artificially rearrange frontiers, as this might provide a cause for future wars.

The Union of Democratic Control became the most important of all the anti-war organisations in Britain, with membership reaching 650,000 by 1917. His political courage was praised by people such as Bertrand Russell and the writer Romain Rolland, but his leading role in the pacifist movement exposed him to violent attacks led by the pro-war press. He was pictured as an agent of Germany in the Daily Express, a newspaper that also listed details of future UDC meetings and encouraged its readers to attend and break them up. The accusation gained some credibility when Roger Casement, who was known as a friend and supporter of Morel, was hanged for treason (he had contacted the Germans seeking support for Irish nationalism). Morel was even the victim of occasional physical assaults.

Imprisonment

On 22 August 1917 Morel's house was searched and evidence was discovered that he had sent a UDC pamphlet to Romain Rolland in Switzerland, a neutral country; this was a breach of the Defence of the Realm Act. Morel was sentenced to six months' imprisonment, which he served in Pentonville Prison. Although, along with other pacifists, he was placed in the 'second division', allowing some privileges over the majority of prisoners, conditions were very hard, and Morel's health was seriously damaged. Bertrand Russell described his condition at his release:

His hair is completely white (there was hardly a tinge of white before) when he first came out, he collapsed completely, physically and mentally, largely as the result of insufficient food. He says one only gets three quarters of an hour reading in the whole day – the rest of the time is spent on prison work, etc.

He was released in January 1918.^[33]

Independent Labour Party membership

In April 1918, he joined the Independent Labour Party, and began to feed his views into the Labour Party to which it was affiliated and which adopted his critical view of the Treaty of Versailles. Morel explained his decision to join the Independent Labour Party to a friend:

I have long been gravitating towards the Socialist position — of course there is Socialism and Socialism, and mine is of the reasonable and moderate kind. When I look over my public efforts through the years, it seems to me that I have been a Socialist all my life. So far as any Party can express what appears to me to be the country's needs, the ILP approximates nearer to my outlook that any other, although I still look forward to and hope for the day when all really progressive forces can unite under the title of the Democratic Party. But Liberalism as represented by both wings — the Lloyd George wing, and the Asquith wing, is right outside my outlook now.

Post-war activism

Treaty of Versailles

Morel was severely critical of the Treaty of Versailles, warning that it would lead to another war. He particularly opposed the assignment of "war guilt" exclusively to the Central Powers and the mandate system for former German colonies. The latter theme became the focus of his 1920 book The Black Man's Burden.^[3]

He did not give up his career as a journalist, becoming director of the magazine Foreign Affairs.^[34]Foreign Affairs became a significant voice of the English left about foreign politics at the time, representing the views of the UDC.^[35] In his articles for the magazine, Morel blamed France and Tsarist Russia—not the Central Powers—for the origins of World War I and was scathingly critical of French imperialism.^[35] Morel's articles also deplored the fate of the new nation of Hungary, which had been part of the Dual Monarchy of Austria-Hungary at the start of World War I.^[34] The former Kingdom of Hungary was stripped of more than two-thirds of its territory and most of its population in the 1920 Treaty of Trianon.^[36] Morel portrayed Hungary as a victim of French rapacity, reduced to "Hopeless, Heart-Breaking Bondage."^[34]

Black Horror on the Rhine

As part of his general opposition to French foreign policy,^[35] Morel played a key role in launching the British-based part of the Black Shame campaign, a racist campaign against the use by the French forces during the occupation of the Rhineland.^[37] In a front-page article in The Daily Herald on 9 April 1920 by Morel about the French occupation of the Rhineland, the headline read ": "Frankfurt runs red with blood French Blood Troops Use Machine-guns on Civilians".^[38] The following day, the same paper had another cover story by Morel, the title of which was "Black Scourge In Europe Sexual Horror Let Loose by France On Rhine Disappearance of Young German Girls". In it, Morel wrote that France is "thrusting her black savages into the heart of Germany", saying that these "primitive African savages, the carriers of syphilis, have become a horror and a terror" to the Rhinelanders.^[38] In his article, Morel claimed that the Senegalese soldiers serving in the French Army were "primitive African barbarians" who "stuffed their haversacks with eye-balls, ears and heads of the foe".^[39] Morel declared in his article:

"There [the Rhineland] they [the Senegealse soldiers] have become a terror and a horror unimaginable to the countryside, raping girls and women-for well known physiological reasons, the raping of a white woman by a negro is nearly always accompanied by serious injuries and not infrequently has fatal results; spreading syphilis, murdering inoffensive civilians, often getting completely out of control; the terrible barbaric incarnation of a barbarous policy, embodied in a so-called peace treaty which puts the clock back 2,000 years".^[39]

Morel wrote that "black savages" have uncontrolled sexual impulses that "must be satisfied upon the bodies of white women!" (emphasis in the original).^[40]

The phrase that Morel coined to describe the alleged terror by Senegalese troops in the Rhineland was the "Black Horror on the Rhine", which became internationally famous, and the campaign against the "black horror" took much of his time for the last four years of his life.^[41] Morel predicated the "black horror" would cause another world war, writing that the average German boy was thinking: "Boys these men raped your mothers and sisters" (emphasis in the original).^[42] Morel used the "black horror" as a way of attacking France which he claimed had caused a “sexual horror on the Rhine” and whose “reign of terror” was a “giant evil” that should inspire “shame into all four corners of the world” and ultimately should “a revision of the Versailles Treaty and the relief for Germany.”^[43]

The German sociologist Iris Wigger wrote that Morel's "Black Horror on the Rhine" campaign has caused much embarrassment to Morel's admirers today who would rather remember the man who campaigned against the Congo Free State, but in fact both campaigns were manifestations of the same racism as Morel believed that all black people were innately stupid and inferior to white people in all respects.^[44] Through Morel had been very forceful in condemning the cruel exploitation of the Congo Free State, Morel believed in a liberal imperialism, just not the cruel exploitative imperialism of the Congo Company, writing it was the duty of whites to serve as the "trustees" for blacks and the "great white father" who would protect the "basic human rights" of Africans while at the same time accepting the "infantile" nature of black people who not the equal in any way of whites.^[45] Morel himself did not see his campaign as racist and he always presented himself as a friend to black people. In France, a French Socialist Charles Gide wrote about Morel's claims to be a protector of Africans that: "le genre de protection de M. Morel rappelle un peu le precepte que fait afficher la Society protectrice des animaux: 'Soyez bons pour les betes'" (Mr. Morel's kind of protection is a little reminiscent of the precepts of the Society for the Protection of Animals: 'Be good to the animals').^[46]

In particular, Morel believed that Africans, lacking the self-discipline of whites, had an uncontrolled sexuality, a subject which he had often written about.^[44] Morel believed that because of the high infant mortality in the tropics that Africans had evolved in such a way as to be obsessed with sex to the exclusion of everything else as they needed a high birth rate to maintain their numbers.^[44] Precisely because Morel believed in the uncontrolled sexuality of blacks, it was self-evident to him that the "sexually uncontrolled and uncontrollable" Senegalese would run amok in the Rhineland, raping every German female in sight.^[47] Two contemporaries challenged Morel on this: Claude McKay, the Jamaican poet and labour activist, and Norman Leys, the British Africanist. Leys stated that such allegations constituted “one of the great sources of race hatred” and “should never be repeated by any honest man or honest newspaper.”^[48]

Morel was very anti-French not only because of his opposition to the Treaty of Versailles, but because of the nature of France's mission civilisatrice ("civilizing mission") in Africa (whereby any African who was willing to embrace the French language and culture would become French and theoretically the equal of whites) threatened to upend Morel's beliefs in the essential biological inferiority of blacks.^[49] Morel believed that the Africans were committing outrageous crimes against Germans in the Rhineland because the French had empowered them by least theoretically making them into black Frenchmen who were just as much citizens of the republic as anyone else.^[49]

Parliament

In the 1922 general election, which followed the retirement of an incumbent Labour Member of Parliament, Alexander Wilkie, Morel fought the two-member Dundee constituency as a sole Labour candidate. Although he gained fewer votes than Edwin Scrymgeour of the Scottish Prohibition Party, he won the second seat, in the process defeating one of the outgoing Members – Winston Churchill, standing as a National Liberal. Morel regarded Churchill as a warmonger and took pride in having defeated him: "I look upon Churchill as such a personal force for evil that I would take up the fight against him with a whole heart."^[50]

With his foreign affairs specialty, he was expected to be appointed as Foreign Secretary in the government of Ramsay MacDonald in 1924, but MacDonald decided to serve as his own Foreign Secretary.^[51] Possibly in compensation, MacDonald led an unsuccessful attempt to nominate Morel for the Nobel Prize for Peace.^[52] In August 1924, Morel is believed to have persuaded MacDonald to recognise the communist government in the Soviet Union and nominations on the Anglo-Soviet trade treaty.^[51]

Shortly after his re-election in the 1924 general election, Morel suffered a fatal heart attack in London.^[51]

Legacy

Arthur Conan Doyle became acquainted with Morel through the work of the Congo Reform Association. In his novel The Lost World (1912), he used Morel as an inspiration for the character of Ed Malone.^[53] Philosopher and activist Bertrand Russell said of Morel, "No other man known to me has had the same heroic simplicity in pursuing and proclaiming political truth."^[54]George Orwell, writing in 1946, described Morel as "heroic but rather forgotten man."^[55] Author Jasper Morel Fforde states that Morel is his great-grandfather.^[56]

In assessing Morel's impact on the Congo, contemporary author Adam Hochschild—whose bestseller King Leopold's Ghost had revived Morel's reputation—wrote:

Did the Congo Reform campaign save millions of lives? For many years, the conventional answer was yes ... but the truth is more somber. Some of the worst abuses in the Congo, such as the kidnapping of hostages, did stop as a result of the publicity. But the near-genocidal death rate in the territory continued for more than a decade under Belgian rule.^[57]

Nonetheless, Hochschild concludes, Morel's movement served two great purposes:

First, they put a remarkable amount of information on the historical record ... The movement's other great achievement is that, among its supporters, it kept alive a tradition, a way of seeing the world, a human capacity for being outraged because pain is being inflicted on another human being, even when that pain is inflicted on someone of another color, in another country ... It is this spirit that underlies organisations like Amnesty International ... and Médecins Sans Frontières.^[57]

Books published

• 
  Affairs of West Africa (1902)


• The British Case in French Congo


• 
  King Leopold's Rule in Africa (1904)


• 
  Red Rubber – The story of the rubber slave trade that flourished in Congo in the year of grace 1906 (1906)


• Great Britain and the Congo


• Nigeria


• 
  Morocco and Diplomacy (1912) (reissued as Ten Years of Secret Diplomacy in 1915)


• 
  Truth and the War (1916)


• Africa and the Peace of Europe


• 
  The Black Man's Burden (1920)


• Thoughts on the War


• The Peace, and Prison


• Pre-War Diplomacy


• Diplomacy Revealed

Notes

References

• Alexander, Nathan G. "E.D. Morel (1873–1924), the Congo Reform Association, and the History of Human Rights." Britain and the World 9, no. 2 (2016): 213-235.


• Campbell, Peter "The “Black Horror on the Rhine”: Idealism, Pacifism, and Racism in Feminism and the Left in the Aftermath of the First World War" pages 471-496 from Social History, Volume XLVII, Issue 94, June 2014


• 
  Hochschild, Adam (1998), King Leopold's Ghost, Pan,
  ISBN 0-330-49233-0.


• Lusane, Clarence Hitler's Black Victims: The Historical Experiences of Afro-Germans, European Blacks, Africans, and African Americans in the Nazi Era, London: Psychology Press, 2002
  ISBN 0415932955.


• Reindeers, Robert "Racialism on the Left: E.D. Morel and the 'Black Horror on the Rhine'" pages 1–28 from International Review of Social History, Volume 13, 1968


• Stanard, Matthew G. Selling the Congo: A history of European pro-empire propaganda and the making of Belgian imperialism (U of Nebraska Press, 2012).


• Wigger, Iris The 'Black Horror on the Rhine' Intersections of Race, Nation, Gender and Class in 1920s Germany London: Macmillan, 2017
  ISBN 978-0-230-34361-0.


• Daniël Vangroenweghe (2004), Rood Rubber – Leopold II en zijn Congo,
  ISBN 90-5617-556-4.

Further reading

• 
  Africanus (1918). The adjustment of the German colonial claims; dedicated to the American and British delegates of the Peace conference. Bern. p. 7. Retrieved 2 November 2009.
  

External links

Wikisource has original works written by or about: E. D. Morell

Wikimedia Commons has media related to E. D. Morel.

• Hansard 1803–2005: contributions in Parliament by E. D. Morel
  


• 
  Catalogue of the Morel papers^{[permanent dead link]} at the Archives Division of the London School of Economics.


• An article on Morel from Liverpool's 'Nerve' magazine


• E.D. Morel, the man and his work, with an introd. by Colonel Wedgwood ([1920]), full text


• Report of the British Consul, Roger Casement, on the Administration of the Congo Free State.


• Journal of Belgian History, Digital Archive


• 
  White King, Red Rubber, Black Death (2003) (TV) on IMDb


• 
  Newspaper clippings about E. D. Morel in the 20th Century Press Archives of the German National Library of Economics (ZBW)