Tricky real integral
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
I'm trying to prove the following:
$$ int_0^{2 pi} e^{cos(2 t)} cos(sin(2 t)) =2pi $$
Numerical analysis agrees with this to very high accuracy, so I'm almost sure it's true. Mathematica gives this answer after thinking for a long, but gives an insane antiderivative in terms of exponential integrals. I'd like to evaluate the integral with purely real methods (I've never done complex analysis), as elegantly as possible.
How can I tackle this integral?
calculus integration definite-integrals
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
I'm trying to prove the following:
$$ int_0^{2 pi} e^{cos(2 t)} cos(sin(2 t)) =2pi $$
Numerical analysis agrees with this to very high accuracy, so I'm almost sure it's true. Mathematica gives this answer after thinking for a long, but gives an insane antiderivative in terms of exponential integrals. I'd like to evaluate the integral with purely real methods (I've never done complex analysis), as elegantly as possible.
How can I tackle this integral?
calculus integration definite-integrals
1
Have you heard of Cauchy integral theorem?
– Frank W.
3 hours ago
It would appear that$$int_0^{2pi}e^{cos at}cos(sin at),mathrm dt=2pi$$at least for all non-zero integer values of $a$.
– user170231
3 hours ago
$x=cos(2t)$ then $dx=-2sin(2t)dt$ and the integral has to be broken up into four parts at intervals with $t=frac{pi}{2}$, each with integrand $frac{1}{2}e^xcos(x)$. Each piece should integrate to $frac{pi}{2}$.
– herb steinberg
3 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
I'm trying to prove the following:
$$ int_0^{2 pi} e^{cos(2 t)} cos(sin(2 t)) =2pi $$
Numerical analysis agrees with this to very high accuracy, so I'm almost sure it's true. Mathematica gives this answer after thinking for a long, but gives an insane antiderivative in terms of exponential integrals. I'd like to evaluate the integral with purely real methods (I've never done complex analysis), as elegantly as possible.
How can I tackle this integral?
calculus integration definite-integrals
I'm trying to prove the following:
$$ int_0^{2 pi} e^{cos(2 t)} cos(sin(2 t)) =2pi $$
Numerical analysis agrees with this to very high accuracy, so I'm almost sure it's true. Mathematica gives this answer after thinking for a long, but gives an insane antiderivative in terms of exponential integrals. I'd like to evaluate the integral with purely real methods (I've never done complex analysis), as elegantly as possible.
How can I tackle this integral?
calculus integration definite-integrals
calculus integration definite-integrals
asked 3 hours ago
NMister
343110
343110
1
Have you heard of Cauchy integral theorem?
– Frank W.
3 hours ago
It would appear that$$int_0^{2pi}e^{cos at}cos(sin at),mathrm dt=2pi$$at least for all non-zero integer values of $a$.
– user170231
3 hours ago
$x=cos(2t)$ then $dx=-2sin(2t)dt$ and the integral has to be broken up into four parts at intervals with $t=frac{pi}{2}$, each with integrand $frac{1}{2}e^xcos(x)$. Each piece should integrate to $frac{pi}{2}$.
– herb steinberg
3 hours ago
add a comment |
1
Have you heard of Cauchy integral theorem?
– Frank W.
3 hours ago
It would appear that$$int_0^{2pi}e^{cos at}cos(sin at),mathrm dt=2pi$$at least for all non-zero integer values of $a$.
– user170231
3 hours ago
$x=cos(2t)$ then $dx=-2sin(2t)dt$ and the integral has to be broken up into four parts at intervals with $t=frac{pi}{2}$, each with integrand $frac{1}{2}e^xcos(x)$. Each piece should integrate to $frac{pi}{2}$.
– herb steinberg
3 hours ago
1
1
Have you heard of Cauchy integral theorem?
– Frank W.
3 hours ago
Have you heard of Cauchy integral theorem?
– Frank W.
3 hours ago
It would appear that$$int_0^{2pi}e^{cos at}cos(sin at),mathrm dt=2pi$$at least for all non-zero integer values of $a$.
– user170231
3 hours ago
It would appear that$$int_0^{2pi}e^{cos at}cos(sin at),mathrm dt=2pi$$at least for all non-zero integer values of $a$.
– user170231
3 hours ago
$x=cos(2t)$ then $dx=-2sin(2t)dt$ and the integral has to be broken up into four parts at intervals with $t=frac{pi}{2}$, each with integrand $frac{1}{2}e^xcos(x)$. Each piece should integrate to $frac{pi}{2}$.
– herb steinberg
3 hours ago
$x=cos(2t)$ then $dx=-2sin(2t)dt$ and the integral has to be broken up into four parts at intervals with $t=frac{pi}{2}$, each with integrand $frac{1}{2}e^xcos(x)$. Each piece should integrate to $frac{pi}{2}$.
– herb steinberg
3 hours ago
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
up vote
6
down vote
Write
$$ I(alpha) = int_{0}^{2pi} e^{alpha cos(2t)}cos(alpha sin(2t)) , dt. $$
Then $I(0) = 2pi$, and for $alpha > 0$,
begin{align*}
I'(alpha)
&= int_{0}^{2pi} left[ e^{alpha cos(2t)}cos(alpha sin(2t))cos(2t) - e^{alpha cos(2t)}sin(alpha sin(2t))sin(2t) right] , dt \
&= left[ frac{1}{2alpha} e^{alphacos(2t)}sin(alphasin(2t)) right]_{0}^{2pi} \
&= 0.
end{align*}
So $I(alpha) = 2pi$ for all $alpha in mathbb{R}$.
A general computation. Let $f$ be analytic on $B(0,R)$. Define $I : [0, R) to mathbb{C}$ by
$$ I(r) = int_{0}^{2pi} f(re^{itheta}) , dtheta. $$
Then
$$ I'(r)
= int_{0}^{2pi} f'(re^{itheta})e^{itheta} , dtheta
= left[ frac{1}{ir} f(re^{itheta}) right]_{0}^{2pi}
= 0 $$
and thus $I$ is constant with the value $I(0) = 2pi f(0)$. The above answer corresponds to the real part of this computation with $f(z) = e^z$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Assuming that you could enjoy special functions.
Consider
$$I=int e^{cos(a t)} cos(sin(a t)),dtqquad text{and}qquad J=int e^{cos(a t)} sin(sin(a t)),dt$$
$$I+iJ=int e^{e^{ i at}},dt=-frac{i}{a}, text{Ei}left(e^{i a t}right)$$
$$I-iJ=int e^{e^{- ia t}},dt=frac{i}{a} , text{Ei}left(e^{- i a t}right)$$ where appear the exponential integral function. This makes
$$I=frac{i }{2 a},left(text{Ei}left(e^{-i a t}right)-text{Ei}left(e^{i a
t}right)right)$$
$$J=-frac{1}{2 a},left(text{Ei}left(e^{-i a t}right)+text{Ei}left(e^{i a t}right)right)$$ For integer values of $a$, the definite integration from $0$ to $2pi$ requires breaking it in $2a$ intervals and, as @user170231 commented, the result is $2pi$ for any $a$.
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
6
down vote
Write
$$ I(alpha) = int_{0}^{2pi} e^{alpha cos(2t)}cos(alpha sin(2t)) , dt. $$
Then $I(0) = 2pi$, and for $alpha > 0$,
begin{align*}
I'(alpha)
&= int_{0}^{2pi} left[ e^{alpha cos(2t)}cos(alpha sin(2t))cos(2t) - e^{alpha cos(2t)}sin(alpha sin(2t))sin(2t) right] , dt \
&= left[ frac{1}{2alpha} e^{alphacos(2t)}sin(alphasin(2t)) right]_{0}^{2pi} \
&= 0.
end{align*}
So $I(alpha) = 2pi$ for all $alpha in mathbb{R}$.
A general computation. Let $f$ be analytic on $B(0,R)$. Define $I : [0, R) to mathbb{C}$ by
$$ I(r) = int_{0}^{2pi} f(re^{itheta}) , dtheta. $$
Then
$$ I'(r)
= int_{0}^{2pi} f'(re^{itheta})e^{itheta} , dtheta
= left[ frac{1}{ir} f(re^{itheta}) right]_{0}^{2pi}
= 0 $$
and thus $I$ is constant with the value $I(0) = 2pi f(0)$. The above answer corresponds to the real part of this computation with $f(z) = e^z$.
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
Write
$$ I(alpha) = int_{0}^{2pi} e^{alpha cos(2t)}cos(alpha sin(2t)) , dt. $$
Then $I(0) = 2pi$, and for $alpha > 0$,
begin{align*}
I'(alpha)
&= int_{0}^{2pi} left[ e^{alpha cos(2t)}cos(alpha sin(2t))cos(2t) - e^{alpha cos(2t)}sin(alpha sin(2t))sin(2t) right] , dt \
&= left[ frac{1}{2alpha} e^{alphacos(2t)}sin(alphasin(2t)) right]_{0}^{2pi} \
&= 0.
end{align*}
So $I(alpha) = 2pi$ for all $alpha in mathbb{R}$.
A general computation. Let $f$ be analytic on $B(0,R)$. Define $I : [0, R) to mathbb{C}$ by
$$ I(r) = int_{0}^{2pi} f(re^{itheta}) , dtheta. $$
Then
$$ I'(r)
= int_{0}^{2pi} f'(re^{itheta})e^{itheta} , dtheta
= left[ frac{1}{ir} f(re^{itheta}) right]_{0}^{2pi}
= 0 $$
and thus $I$ is constant with the value $I(0) = 2pi f(0)$. The above answer corresponds to the real part of this computation with $f(z) = e^z$.
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
up vote
6
down vote
Write
$$ I(alpha) = int_{0}^{2pi} e^{alpha cos(2t)}cos(alpha sin(2t)) , dt. $$
Then $I(0) = 2pi$, and for $alpha > 0$,
begin{align*}
I'(alpha)
&= int_{0}^{2pi} left[ e^{alpha cos(2t)}cos(alpha sin(2t))cos(2t) - e^{alpha cos(2t)}sin(alpha sin(2t))sin(2t) right] , dt \
&= left[ frac{1}{2alpha} e^{alphacos(2t)}sin(alphasin(2t)) right]_{0}^{2pi} \
&= 0.
end{align*}
So $I(alpha) = 2pi$ for all $alpha in mathbb{R}$.
A general computation. Let $f$ be analytic on $B(0,R)$. Define $I : [0, R) to mathbb{C}$ by
$$ I(r) = int_{0}^{2pi} f(re^{itheta}) , dtheta. $$
Then
$$ I'(r)
= int_{0}^{2pi} f'(re^{itheta})e^{itheta} , dtheta
= left[ frac{1}{ir} f(re^{itheta}) right]_{0}^{2pi}
= 0 $$
and thus $I$ is constant with the value $I(0) = 2pi f(0)$. The above answer corresponds to the real part of this computation with $f(z) = e^z$.
Write
$$ I(alpha) = int_{0}^{2pi} e^{alpha cos(2t)}cos(alpha sin(2t)) , dt. $$
Then $I(0) = 2pi$, and for $alpha > 0$,
begin{align*}
I'(alpha)
&= int_{0}^{2pi} left[ e^{alpha cos(2t)}cos(alpha sin(2t))cos(2t) - e^{alpha cos(2t)}sin(alpha sin(2t))sin(2t) right] , dt \
&= left[ frac{1}{2alpha} e^{alphacos(2t)}sin(alphasin(2t)) right]_{0}^{2pi} \
&= 0.
end{align*}
So $I(alpha) = 2pi$ for all $alpha in mathbb{R}$.
A general computation. Let $f$ be analytic on $B(0,R)$. Define $I : [0, R) to mathbb{C}$ by
$$ I(r) = int_{0}^{2pi} f(re^{itheta}) , dtheta. $$
Then
$$ I'(r)
= int_{0}^{2pi} f'(re^{itheta})e^{itheta} , dtheta
= left[ frac{1}{ir} f(re^{itheta}) right]_{0}^{2pi}
= 0 $$
and thus $I$ is constant with the value $I(0) = 2pi f(0)$. The above answer corresponds to the real part of this computation with $f(z) = e^z$.
edited 3 hours ago
answered 3 hours ago
Sangchul Lee
90.6k12163262
90.6k12163262
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Assuming that you could enjoy special functions.
Consider
$$I=int e^{cos(a t)} cos(sin(a t)),dtqquad text{and}qquad J=int e^{cos(a t)} sin(sin(a t)),dt$$
$$I+iJ=int e^{e^{ i at}},dt=-frac{i}{a}, text{Ei}left(e^{i a t}right)$$
$$I-iJ=int e^{e^{- ia t}},dt=frac{i}{a} , text{Ei}left(e^{- i a t}right)$$ where appear the exponential integral function. This makes
$$I=frac{i }{2 a},left(text{Ei}left(e^{-i a t}right)-text{Ei}left(e^{i a
t}right)right)$$
$$J=-frac{1}{2 a},left(text{Ei}left(e^{-i a t}right)+text{Ei}left(e^{i a t}right)right)$$ For integer values of $a$, the definite integration from $0$ to $2pi$ requires breaking it in $2a$ intervals and, as @user170231 commented, the result is $2pi$ for any $a$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Assuming that you could enjoy special functions.
Consider
$$I=int e^{cos(a t)} cos(sin(a t)),dtqquad text{and}qquad J=int e^{cos(a t)} sin(sin(a t)),dt$$
$$I+iJ=int e^{e^{ i at}},dt=-frac{i}{a}, text{Ei}left(e^{i a t}right)$$
$$I-iJ=int e^{e^{- ia t}},dt=frac{i}{a} , text{Ei}left(e^{- i a t}right)$$ where appear the exponential integral function. This makes
$$I=frac{i }{2 a},left(text{Ei}left(e^{-i a t}right)-text{Ei}left(e^{i a
t}right)right)$$
$$J=-frac{1}{2 a},left(text{Ei}left(e^{-i a t}right)+text{Ei}left(e^{i a t}right)right)$$ For integer values of $a$, the definite integration from $0$ to $2pi$ requires breaking it in $2a$ intervals and, as @user170231 commented, the result is $2pi$ for any $a$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
Assuming that you could enjoy special functions.
Consider
$$I=int e^{cos(a t)} cos(sin(a t)),dtqquad text{and}qquad J=int e^{cos(a t)} sin(sin(a t)),dt$$
$$I+iJ=int e^{e^{ i at}},dt=-frac{i}{a}, text{Ei}left(e^{i a t}right)$$
$$I-iJ=int e^{e^{- ia t}},dt=frac{i}{a} , text{Ei}left(e^{- i a t}right)$$ where appear the exponential integral function. This makes
$$I=frac{i }{2 a},left(text{Ei}left(e^{-i a t}right)-text{Ei}left(e^{i a
t}right)right)$$
$$J=-frac{1}{2 a},left(text{Ei}left(e^{-i a t}right)+text{Ei}left(e^{i a t}right)right)$$ For integer values of $a$, the definite integration from $0$ to $2pi$ requires breaking it in $2a$ intervals and, as @user170231 commented, the result is $2pi$ for any $a$.
Assuming that you could enjoy special functions.
Consider
$$I=int e^{cos(a t)} cos(sin(a t)),dtqquad text{and}qquad J=int e^{cos(a t)} sin(sin(a t)),dt$$
$$I+iJ=int e^{e^{ i at}},dt=-frac{i}{a}, text{Ei}left(e^{i a t}right)$$
$$I-iJ=int e^{e^{- ia t}},dt=frac{i}{a} , text{Ei}left(e^{- i a t}right)$$ where appear the exponential integral function. This makes
$$I=frac{i }{2 a},left(text{Ei}left(e^{-i a t}right)-text{Ei}left(e^{i a
t}right)right)$$
$$J=-frac{1}{2 a},left(text{Ei}left(e^{-i a t}right)+text{Ei}left(e^{i a t}right)right)$$ For integer values of $a$, the definite integration from $0$ to $2pi$ requires breaking it in $2a$ intervals and, as @user170231 commented, the result is $2pi$ for any $a$.
answered 15 mins ago
Claude Leibovici
116k1156131
116k1156131
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3020916%2ftricky-real-integral%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
1
Have you heard of Cauchy integral theorem?
– Frank W.
3 hours ago
It would appear that$$int_0^{2pi}e^{cos at}cos(sin at),mathrm dt=2pi$$at least for all non-zero integer values of $a$.
– user170231
3 hours ago
$x=cos(2t)$ then $dx=-2sin(2t)dt$ and the integral has to be broken up into four parts at intervals with $t=frac{pi}{2}$, each with integrand $frac{1}{2}e^xcos(x)$. Each piece should integrate to $frac{pi}{2}$.
– herb steinberg
3 hours ago